The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development's (HUD) Office of Inspector General audited HUD's community service and self-sufficiency requirement (the requirement) as a result of news media reports that the requirement is rarely enforced. Our audit objective was to determine whether HUD ensured that housing authorities properly administered the requirement.

We found that HUD did not have adequate controls to ensure that housing authorities properly administered the requirement. Specifically, HUD did not have sufficient guidelines, adequate data collection and reporting systems, or effective enforcement mechanisms. Of 68 statistically selected households, 44 households did not comply with the requirement and were, therefore, ineligible for continued occupancy. Based on these results, we estimate that housing authorities improperly renewed or extended the leases of at least 85,000 ineligible households costing an estimated $21.5 million in monthly operating subsidies.

We recommend that HUD improve its controls to ensure that housing authorities properly administer the requirement, resulting in more than $257 million being put to better use annually. We also recommend that HUD require housing authorities to take corrective action against the 44 ineligible households identified as part of our statistical sample review.