We audited the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development’s (HUD) oversight of Federal Housing Administration (FHA) refunds based on a hotline complaint alleging that HUD was trying to make it difficult for claimants to obtain refunds or discourage them from pursuing the refunds, which are due to eligible homeowners from the unearned portion of the upfront mortgage insurance premium paid. Our audit found the allegations from the hotline complaint submitted to the HUD Office of Inspector General had some merit. Also, HUD did not have adequate controls in place to ensure that refunds were appropriately tracked, monitored, and issued. Specifically, HUD (1) did not ensure that the homeowner information for at least 23,579 loans with unpaid refunds totaling approximately $15.8 million was included in its public listing of unpaid refunds, (2) did not adequately track the status of refunds, (3) lacked policies and procedures for various stages of the refund process, (4) did not fully implement procedures it developed requiring additional documents from homeowners, and (5) did not follow the requirements of the Paperwork Reduction Act. This condition occurred because HUD did not emphasize reviewing or monitoring the refund process to identify weaknesses and focused primarily on sending refund applications and issuing refunds to homeowners who returned the applications. As a result, HUD could not ensure that it implemented a consistent refund process, and homeowners and third-party tracers were not able to search for all refunds HUD owed, which may have reduced the chance for homeowners for at least 23,579 loans to obtain approximately $15.8 million in refunds. We recommended that the Deputy Assistant Secretary for Finance and Budget (1) develop and implement written policies and procedures and controls for the refund process to address the deficiencies identified, (2) develop, and implement policies and procedures for locating homeowners, a standard timeframe for mailing refund applications, and verifying the termination date, (3) research, develop, and implement policies and procedures to reduce the number of refunds that have remained unclaimed for an extended period, (4) develop and implement controls for the designation of legal representation for applicants, (5) ensure that the requirements that were developed for additional documents for identification are fully implemented, and (6) obtain approval under the Paperwork Reduction Act for the insert document mailed with the refund application and the Tracer Found Case form.
|2022-LA-0001-001-A||Cerrado||Enero 07, 2022||Develop and implement written policies and procedures and controls for the FHA refund process to address the deficiencies identified in the audit report. These should include (1) controls to ensure that the website for the public listing of all unpaid refunds is complete, (2) controls to ensure that refund applications are sent only to the homeowners who requested them, (3) controls to ensure that refund applications are sent to all homeowners on the loan after loan termination, and (4) a formal monitoring framework for tracking the status of refunds.|
|2022-LA-0001-001-B||Abierta||Enero 07, 2022||Develop and implement written policies and procedures (1) for locating homeowners who have unpaid refunds (for both existing and new refunds), (2) to establish a standard timeframe for mailing refund applications to homeowners after they are requested, and (3) to establish requirements for verifying the termination date based on supporting documents provided by homeowners.|
|2022-LA-0001-001-C||Abierta||Enero 07, 2022||Research, develop, and implement policies and procedures to reduce the number of refunds that have remained unclaimed for an extended period, including consideration of a statute of limitations.|
|2022-LA-0001-001-D||Abierta||Enero 07, 2022||Develop and implement written policies and procedures regarding the designation of legal representation for applicants.|
|2022-LA-0001-001-E||Abierta||Enero 07, 2022||Obtain the required approvals under the Paperwork Reduction Act for the insert document mailed with the refund application and the Tracer Found Case form.|